How would you rate the current state of peer review in your field?

Answer Explanations

• Excellent - working very well

  user-958242
  Getting mainly peer review tasks from area of expertise.
• Fair - significant room for improvement

  user-983537
  Many reviews are superficial, uncritical, non-constructive, unnecessarily adversarial or self-promoting
• Fair - significant room for improvement

  user-858214
  A lot of publications are rather descriptive than scientific
• Good - mostly effective with minor issues

  user-709065
  NOT APPLICABLE